Media Portrayals of Women: Gone Girl & My Year of Rest & Relaxation.

BY MISHKA.

The portrayal of women in media is subject to intense scrutiny and debate, as it has the power to shape societal perceptions, attitudes, and behaviours. Through mediums such as film and literature, nuanced narratives about femininity are constructed, influencing how individuals perceive and interact with the world around them. In this think piece, we will embark on a comprehensive exploration of the impact of media portrayals of women, focusing on two seminal works: the film “Gone Girl” and the book “My Year of Rest and Relaxation”. By delving into the psychological underpinnings of these narratives, we can uncover the intricate ways in which they shape societal norms and individual psyches.

Gone Girl:

In “Gone Girl”, the enigmatic character of Amy Dunne emerges as a captivating study in

manipulation and deception, challenging conventional notions of female passivity and victimhood. Amy’s cunning manoeuvres and calculated actions captivate audiences, blurring the lines between heroism and villainy. Through the lens of psychology, we can interpret Amy’s character as a manifestation of complex psychological constructs such as Machiavellianism and narcissism. Her portrayal not only challenges gender stereotypes but also offers a compelling exploration of the darker facets of human nature.

One positive impact of Amy’s portrayal lies in its ability to spark critical conversations about gender roles and power dynamics. By subverting traditional tropes and expectations, “Gone Girl” invites viewers to interrogate societal norms and question the complexities of human behaviour. Moreover, Amy’s character serves as a testament to the multidimensionality of women, challenging the notion of monolithic representations in media.

However, the portrayal of Amy Dunne also carries potential negative implications, as it risks

reinforcing harmful stereotypes about women as manipulative and deceitful. Without proper context and critical engagement, viewers may internalise these stereotypes, perpetuating gender-based biases and misconceptions. It is essential for audiences to approach Amy’s character with nuance and scepticism, recognising the complexities of her portrayal and its broader societal implications.

My Year of Rest and Relaxation:

In “My Year of Rest and Relaxation”, the protagonist’s quest for emotional detachment serves as a poignant critique of societal pressures placed on women to conform to idealised standards of femininity. Through her journey of self-discovery and rebellion against societal expectations, the protagonist challenges ingrained stereotypes and norms. Drawing from self-determination theory, we can interpret the protagonist’s actions as a quest for autonomy and authenticity in a world defined by conformity.

One positive impact of “My Year of Rest and Relaxation” lies in its celebration of female agency and autonomy. Her journey may inspire individuals to question the validity of societal norms and prioritise self-discovery.

However, the portrayal of the protagonist’s extreme measures to escape societal pressures may also have negative implications, as it risks glorifying unhealthy coping mechanisms. Without proper context and critical analysis, readers may interpret the protagonist’s actions as a viable solution to their own struggles, neglecting the importance of seeking support and professional help. It is crucial for audiences to approach the protagonist’s journey with caution, recognising the complexities of mental health and the need for nuanced discussions about coping strategies.

The portrayal of women in media is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon with far-reaching implications for society. Moving forward, it is imperative for creators, consumers, and critics of media to engage in nuanced discussions about the portrayal of women, fostering a more inclusive and empowering media landscape for all.

—

Mishka, 2024

Qatar, Doha